Joe Cristiano's Pizza

Located in the heart of Poughkeepsie, NY, Joe Cristiano's Pizza is a beloved local gem that expertly serves up classic Italian-American flavors with a twist of homegrown charm. Specializing in pizza, chicken wings, and Italian favorites, this cozy eatery delivers a satisfying experience whether you're dining in, grabbing a quick takeaway, or enjoying their convenient delivery service.

Joe Cristiano’s menu is a celebration of hearty, comforting dishes crafted with care. Their standout Meatball Sliders burst with juicy, savory meatballs nestled in soft rolls — the perfect handheld indulgence. Garlic Knots arrive airy and golden, with just the right balance of buttery garlic and herbs that instantly awaken your palate. Traditional Wings boast a crispy texture with robust flavor, while the BBQ Pizza offers a smoky, tangy twist on the classic pie, delivering an irresistible combination of flavors that delight from the first bite.

For those with a sweet tooth, the dessert selection is equally impressive. The Cannoli, filled with Joe’s signature homemade cream, is a creamy, crisp delight, perfectly complemented by the rich, velvety New York Style Cheesecake. Other treats like freshly baked Chocolate Chip Cookies and Oreo Pie provide a comforting end to any meal, showcasing their dedication to quality and traditional tastes.

Joe Cristiano’s also caters to diverse dietary preferences. Their 14" Plant-Based 4 Cheese Blend pizza made with hand-tossed Daiya cheese and house-made red sauce offers a compassionate option without compromising on taste—proof that great pizza truly is for everyone.

The atmosphere at Joe Cristiano's matches the warmth of its food. Whether you’re dropping by at the casual spot on Salt Point Turnpike or settling in for a meal, the vibe is friendly and welcoming, making guests feel like part of a community that values great food and excellent service.

Customers consistently praise Joe Cristiano’s for its reliability and generous portions. Michael Englese appreciated the punctual delivery and satisfying pizza size, while Jasmin Nappi raved about the rich, thick slices of cheese pizza reminiscent of New York City's finest pizzerias. Regulars, like DoBeDoBeDo Inc., highlight the consistently great food, timely service, and rewarding promos that enhance each visit, cementing Joe Cristiano’s as a cherished hometown favorite.

In every dish and interaction, Joe Cristiano's Pizza offers more than just a meal—it delivers a heartfelt tribute to Italian-American culinary tradition, served with genuine hospitality. Whether you’re craving a classic slice, a plate of wings, or a sweet finish, this pizzeria stands out as a trusted spot where authenticity and flavor come first.